NZVS logo Search Facebook Twitter

Animals off the menu?

ANIMALS OFF THE MENU?

Learning area: English
Years: 8-11
Curriculum level: 5

Download this Lesson Plan

Achievement Objectives

Students will:

  • Integrate sources of information, processes, and strategies purposefully and confidently to identify, form, and express increasingly sophisticated ideas.
  • Show an understanding of how language features are used for effect within and across texts.
  • Show an understanding of how to shape texts for different audiences and purposes.
  • Select, develop, and communicate purposeful ideas on a range of topics.

Key Competencies: Thinking, using language, symbols and texts, relating to others.

Lesson and assignment outline

Students will identify and discuss the main ideas, concepts and points of view in the Wheeler Centre’s 2012 debate Animals Should Be Off the Menu. Students will analyse how language features position listeners to respond in a particular way and use this knowledge to create and deliver a speech that informs, persuades and engages an audience on a chosen topic.

Learning outcomes

Students are learning to

  • Identify the main ideas and points of view in a
  • Use evidence to support or challenge different perspectives in relations to animal rights and
  • Create purposeful texts that inform, persuade and engage.
  • Think critically and ethically about meat consumption in the industrialised world.

Reference links: Video link of the debate Animals Should Be Off the Menu (110 minutes in length):

www.wheelercentre.com/broadcasts/intelligence-squared-animals-should-be-off-the-menu

and summary notes of the debate:

www.wheelercentre.com/notes/22b6c7dc3f5e

Corresponding worksheet: Writing a Persuasive Speech

Lesson

1. As a class, brainstorm arguments for and against eating meat. Some reasons for eating meat may include: taste, convenience, and tradition. Some reasons against it may include: environmental, animal welfare, animal rights, health, and food.

2. Play the debate Animals Should Be Off the Menu in class, or assign students to watch the full video at home. If you’re short on time, select shorter segments of the debate which can be found on

3. As a class, ask students to identify the main idea and point of view of each speaker in the debate. Write student answers on the board.

4. Next, ask students to think about which language features are employed by each speaker to persuade their listeners. Some responses may include the use of humour, silent pauses, body language and gestures, rhetorical questions, formal/casual tone, repetition, and colloquial language. Focus on how the tone and manner of the speeches shape listeners’ interpretations. What pieces of evidence are used by speakers to persuade their audience?

Assignment: Ask students to write a four-minute speech to persuade their audience to consider and adopt a certain point of view. Using the Writing a Persuasive Speech worksheet, students may examine any topic relating to animals used for human purposes and choose to represent any argument they wish. (For the purposes of the THINK KIND competition, the argument would need to be pro keeping animals off the menu.)
Topic ideas include:

  • Wool, fur, sheepskin and leather
  • Testing cosmetic and household products
  • Greyhound racing and horse racing
  • Zoos, marine parks and aquariums
  • Circuses and mobile animal farms
  • Animal dissection and/or scientific vivisection
  • Chick hatching programs
  • Meat, dairy and eggs

Students should use evidence to support their argument, presenting visual evidence such as slideshows, posters, graphs or props.

Evaluation

Use the following rubric to self and peer assess student speeches:

  • Demonstrates a deliberate use of persuasive
  • Demonstrates an understanding of key terms and provides clear definitions where
  • Uses visual material as evidence to support their
  • Uses a clear voice.
  • Presents information in a logical, interesting, and easy-to-follow
  • Demonstrates knowledge of their chosen

Wrap-up discussion questions

Why do you think audience members of the Animals Should Be Off the Menu debate were persuaded to change their position?

Did any of the key speakers in the debate compel you to reconsider your own point of view? Give examples.

What kind of evidence or language features are most effective in persuading listeners to adopt a point of view?

Writing a persuasive speech worksheet